Identification of Plant Diseases

Introduction

It is important to keep food available and plentiful.  In food we get energy, which starts with the sun and the plants (and algae). These photosynthetic organisms are the backbone of our food supply.  If you lived on candy bars and lobsters, you are still relying on plants and algae.  Sugar from sugarcane or sugar beats is used to make candy bars, while lobsters dine on microscopic algae. Both grow using sunlight.  As these photosynthetic organisms are the source of all food, there is a need to keep them healthy. For those organisms we selectively cultivate, that is crops, it is important to make the plants heartier and producing greater yields when harvested.  Scientists, in such jobs as plant pathologists, botanists, breeders, and biochemists, are responsible for keeping plants healthy and making them better.

Many different types of scientists work together to develop crops and keep them healthy. Plant breeders and geneticists develop new varieties of crops with desirable traits, such as higher yields, better nutrition, resistance to disease, or the ability to tolerate drought and heat. Molecular biologists and biotechnologists study plant DNA and can use techniques such as genetic engineering and gene editing to introduce or improve useful traits. Plant physiologists study how plants grow and respond to environmental conditions, including variations in water, temperature, nutrients, and sunlight.

Other scientists concentrate on keeping crops healthy after they are planted. Plant pathologists study diseases caused by fungi, bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms, while entomologists study insects that can damage crops. Soil scientists and agronomists study soil fertility, fertilizers, irrigation, and farming practices that help crops grow efficiently. Weed scientists help control plants that compete with crops for water, nutrients, and sunlight. Together, these scientists help farmers produce healthy crops while dealing with pests, diseases, changing weather, and the need to feed a growing population.

There are many scientists involved with putting food on our tables.  In this story, you have the opportunity to see how science is applied by taking on the role of a plant pathologist.

Scenario

Zea mays, commonly known as corn, is a very important commodity crop.  In 2025, approximately 17 billion bushels of corn were produced with a value of $70 billion USD.  It is used for everything from corn bread to animal feed to gasohol to paper.  Basically, it is important to the livelihood of many people.  There are many microorganisms that can infect corn and hurt the plant. A plant pathologist’s job is to protect crops, such as corn.

Corn, and all crops, are constantly being threatened by microorganisms that can harm plants.  These harmful microbes are referred to as pathogens, and include viruses, bacteria, fungi, and nematodes.  These pathogens can attack a plant at different stages of their development, such as during germination and development of the shoots and leaves, to killing flowers and infecting fruit and vegetables. 

Plant diseases can be devastating to the plant and the farmer, and indirectly to the consumer.  It is possible for entire crops to be lost to plant disease.  To prevent crop loss, there are teams of scientists who work together to prevent and investigate problems that arise with plants. These scientists look at problems associated with the entire process with the plant, from preparing the soil for planting to preventing spoilage of fruits and vegetables in the supermarket.

In this scenario, you will take on the role of one of the scientists. The plant pathologist is an individual responsible for identifying the pathogen that is causing the disease.

Picture yourself as a plant pathologist.  You receive a call from a farmer who is worried that one of his fields is infected with a disease they don’t recognize.  The farmer describes plants that emerge from the soil without a problem, but as the season progresses, the plants become stunted, yellow, and eventually wilt and die.  This problem was observed during the previous growing season, but it was limited to a few square yards of corn.  This year the problem spread to a much larger area.  The farmer is asking for your help so they can identify the problem and take steps to prevent the issue next year.

What do you do? Think of this process as if you are a detective investigating a crime. First you would visit the crime scene and look around. Next you would carefully examine the scene of the crime, in detail, perhaps taking samples and gathering evidence. You would then head to the forensics lab and analyze the evidence. With all the information in hand, you could try to summarize the problem. With plants, the summary may be followed by a solution you could provide the farmer.

Thus, some logical steps would be:

  1. Travel out to the field and perform a survey
  2. Collect a sample of healthy and disease plants for analysis
  3. Perform microbiological analysis of the samples
  4. Perform genetic analysis on the samples
  5. Check with surrounding farms to see if the problem is widespread
  6. Summarize findings and draw conclusions

Why are each of these steps important?

Field Survey: A plant pathologist can always find microorganisms in healthy and diseased plant samples, but the findings becomes meaningful only when integrated with symptoms, disease pattern, sample quality, and field history.

Collect Samples: Both healthy and diseased plants need to be collected, bagged separately, labeled, and stored for shipment to the plant pathology lab. The samples should ideally be of the entire plant, roots and all. In many cases, as with diseased trees, sending the entire sample is impossible, so at a minimum, representative healthy and diseased tissue is needed.

Microbiological Analysis: Fungi, bacteria, and nematodes isolated from plants using culturing techniques on culture media can reveal both the native and pathogenic microorganisms associated with the plants. Many times the pathogen will be easy to identify, but at times may require extensive culturing and biochemical tests.

Genetic Analysis: All organisms, microbiological and otherwise, have unique DNA sequences, or genetic fingerprints, that can be used to identify the organism. With microorganisms, sequences with in genes coding for ribosomes can determine the difference between microbial species. Isolating the DNA and performing a process called sequencing will yield a DNA sequence. That sequence can be analyzed by comparing it to a database that contains hundreds of thousands of previously sequenced microorganisms.

Survey the Surrounding Area: If a disease is new and devastating, it is wise to inspect nearby fields and farms to determine if the problem extends beyond the problem field. Some plant disease can be severe and cause catastrophic problems for farmers and local economies. A classic examine is citrus greening (Huanglongbing) caused by a bacteria that is causing huge problems in the citrus industry.

What To Do With The Data?

Once data has been collected and samples analyzed in the laboratory, a compilation of the information is needed, along with conclusions. Often the disease might be previously know, and remedies might be readily available, however many new diseases are appearing that have no treatment. These diseases are usually investigated in greater detail so that both the organisms and a potential treatment can be better understood.

Assignment: As you proceed through this investigation, keep a notebook of what information you find so that you can draw conclusions later. Everything is important: a survey protocol, data table with sample sizes, disease map, incidence and severity calculations, interpretation of risk factors, and targeted sampling recommendation.

All the information should recorded and determined later whether it is relevant. Note that:

  1. Field observations show symptoms, affected tissues, and spatial pattern but they do not identify the causal organism.
  2. Microbiological examination can identify was is in the sample, but doesn’t verify it is the problem.
  3. DNA extraction and sequencing can show whether target genetic material is detectable, but detection alone does not prove causation.
  4. An epidemiological survey can show distribution, incidence, severity, and possible risk factors, but it cannot establish a definitive diagnosis without biological or molecular confirmation.

One thing that is very typical with scientific investigations is that you never get a concrete answer. Often data will suggest an answer, but there is always a chance, or probability, that conclusions are wrong. Being diligent in the investigation helps in drawing conclusions that are accepted.

The Final Task

Prepare a plant health report for the farmer. State the leading diagnosis or differential diagnosis, summarize the evidence, explain limitations, and recommend the next action. Possible recommendations include additional sampling, laboratory confirmation, sanitation, crop rotation, drainage improvement, resistant varieties, vector management, or consultation with an extension plant pathologist.

Things to Consider

  1. Why is a field pattern important before a sample is sent to a diagnostic laboratory?
  2. Why should a diagnostic laboratory receive both symptomatic and healthy comparison material?
  3. What is the difference between detecting a pathogen and proving that it caused disease?
  4. How can an epidemiological survey help a plant pathologist decide which samples to test?
  5.  Which additional scientist would you involve next, and what question would that scientist help answer?